12th Congressional District

Rush Holt is the current incumbent for the 12th District of New Jersey. He is rated the most liberal member of the House. His legislative accomplishments are so thin its more likely he is just a loyal vote for other liberals. In fact, he has voted with his party on major issues 98% of the time.

Is he vulnerable? Well the 12th district has been gerrymandered to give democrats a considerable edge in the district. There are roughly 140,000 registered Democrats versus 80,000 registered Republicans in the district. Holt has consistently won with over 60% of the vote.

However, this is the year of anti-incumbent sentiment and anti-liberal sentiment. Governor Christie defeated Corzine in the 12th district just 4 months ago. It is possible. A couple things have to happen. Democrats must remain disappointed and unenthusiastic to the point that less than 40% actually show up. I think only 35% of them actually showed in the governor's election (just my estimate). Second, Republicans need to come out en mass. Unfortunately they never have due to apathy. Why vote when they are so outnumbered and have never gotten close to competing with Rush Holt? Also the Republican Party has lost a lot of support in the past 5 years. Finally, independents need to break for the Republcian candidate about 2-to-1.

So the NJ 12th needs a Scott Brown and a horrible incumbent. As liberal as Holt is, he is probably not as unpopular as Corzine. Corzine had high negatives. He is within reach if Republicans unite and independents show up strong. Currently Scott Sipprelle, Mike Halfacre, and David Corsi are running for the Republican nomination. I have made no secret that I like Sipprelle but am not necessarily averse to Halfacre and Corsi. But from what I have seen, Halfacre and Corsi don't have the necessary campaign skills to win in June or November. They can't seem to raise money or obtain significant local party support. Halfacre in particular had 8 months with no primary opponents and failed to raise $100,000 and his local party support is eroding fast. Sipprelle is self-financing but has also managed to gain substantial local party support.

A lot has been made of the local Tea Parties but not all Tea Parties are created equal. Some are small, disorganized, and really aren't significant grassroots groups. Five groups have supposedly endorsed Mike Halfacre. But so far it seems it will not translate to getting the line in Middlesex County. If the Tea Partiers are mostly centered in Monmouth, Halfacre could still win the nomination since most Republicans in the district live in the Monmouth and eastern Middlesex areas. But my take is that these Tea Parties are either not that large or not that enamored with Halfacre.

We will all know more after the Middlesex County Republican Convention in March 27th.